Livingston 0-0 Partick Thistle

Partick defender Willie Kinniburgh gets to grips with Steven Craig

The all-First Division Scottish Cup encounter ended in a drab stalemate as neither side did enough to win.

Thistle's Simon Donnelly came closest to scoring in an uneveventful first half when his goal-bound header was superbly palmed away by Colin Stewart.

Livingston's first attempt on goal came in the 70th minute when Robert Snodgrass's free-kick flashed wide.

And Graeme Dorrans had a great chance to win the tie late on but his effort summed up the afternoon's play - poor.

---

Livingston: Stewart, MacKay, James, McPake, McCaffrey (MacDonald 88), Makel, Dorrans, Walker (Griffiths 88), Craig, Fox, Snodgrass. Subs Not Used: Weir, Jacobs, Lunn.

Booked: Walker.

Partick: Tuffey, Robertson, Twaddle, Storey, Kinniburgh, Archibald, Chaplain, Rowson, Buchanan (McStay 83), Donnelly (Keegan 65), Harkins (Murray 73). Subs Not Used: Hinchcliffe, McKinlay.

Booked: Storey, Archibald.

Ref: K Clark (Scotland).